Montauk Yacht Club Hotel | Montauk ★ Book Spa Rooms, Wellness Deals & Guest Reviews

Book here and pay

10% less

than on Booking.com!

Key details

About the Hotel

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

View all

Choose your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Guest Room

Max:

4 persons

360 sq. feet

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Balcony

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Villa

Max:

3 persons

360 sq. feet

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

Heating

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Deluxe Room

Max:

2 persons

360 sq. feet

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Sea view

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

Comprehensive guide to transport options for seamless travel

City Center

Montauk 2.5 mi

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 69.7 mi

Tweed-New Haven (HVN) 107.4 mi

What our guests says about facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Delicious Showfish

The dining experience at Showfish was amazing! The tuna steak was particularly excellent, and the curry sunchokes still linger in my memory. The high-quality ingredients really elevated each dish. I can't imagine coming back without tasting their menu again.

Emily Johnson. United States, 2024-05-10Read full review on

Great Tennis Courts

The har-tru tennis courts available at the hotel were a fantastic surprise! They were well-groomed and perfect for a friendly match with my family. Playing tennis while enjoying the pleasant weather was a highlight of our trip.

Mike_TennisLover. Australia, 2024-08-15Read full review on

Spotless Upgrade

We were pleasantly surprised by the cleanliness and modern touches in our upgraded room. The bathroom had an excellent shower pressure that made our mornings feel refreshing and luxurious. A perfect blend of comfort and style!

Sarah Williams. United Kingdom, 2024-02-23Read full review on

Heated Pool Bliss

The heated outdoor pool maintained at 86 degrees was a dream! We lounged and enjoyed the warm water even when the temperatures outside were lower. It created a cozy and inviting atmosphere for relaxation.

ThomasGoods. Canada, 2024-12-05Read full review on

What’s included

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi in public areas
Paid parking
Safe deposit box
24-hour reception
Pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
24-hour security
Baggage storage
Private beach
Allergy-free rooms
ATM/Cash machine
Coffee shop
Fireplace
Smoke detectors
Electric vehicle charging station
Fire extinguishers
Key card access
Key access

Sports & Fitness

Fitness center
Water sports
Hiking
Cycling
Tennis court
Golf course
Fishing

Services

Pet amenities available
Room service
Housekeeping
Laundry
Dry cleaning
Welcome drink

Dining

Restaurant
Snack bar
Bar/ Lounge area
Special diet menus

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Children

Children's pool

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Seasonal indoor pool
Beach access
Spa & wellness center

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Mini-bar
Sitting area
Patio
Terrace
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Bathtub
Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

Map view

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

City landmarks

50 S Fairview Ave

Montauk Downs State Park

1.4 mi

W Lake Dr

Gosman's Dock

1.3 mi

Golf Course

Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course

1.4 mi

Parks

Shadmoor State Park

2.1 mi

Farm

Rita's Stable

1.7 mi

Farm

Deep Hollow Ranch

2.1 mi

67 South Essex Street

Saint Therese of Lisieux Church

2.3 mi

18 Ditch Plains Rd

Ditch Plains Beach

2.2 mi

Parks

Fort Pond Bay Park

2.5 mi

Museums

Second House Museum

2.8 mi

Parks

Camp Hero State Park

2.5 mi

Store

Sunset Surf Shack

2.5 mi

Parks

Kirk Park Beach

2.8 mi

Montauk

Lake Montauk

2.8 mi

Fort Pond Bay

2.7 mi

1898 Montauk Hwy

Camp Hero

3.0 mi

Lighthouse

Montauk Point Lighthouse

4.0 mi

Nearby

Marina

Star Island Yacht Club and Marina

1200 ft

Restaurants

Star Island Grill

400 ft

Star Island Rd

Westlake Fish House

2700 ft

352 W Lake Dr

Swallow East Restaurant

1.2 mi

474 W Lake Dr

Grey Lady

4900 ft

440 W Lake Dr

Tiny Harbor Asian Cafe

4900 ft

440 W Lake Dr Unit B

The Dock

1.1 mi

482 West Lake Dr

Reviews and Ratings

Reviews from guests about their experience.

88%

loved their spa retreat and can’t wait to return.

Modern room upgrades

Exceptional staff service

Dining options could expand

Price on the higher side

8.8/10

Great

Rooms

9.2

Location

9.0

Service

8.8

Dining

8.6

3.5/5 based on 80 reviews

#25 of 39 hotels in Montauk based on Tripadvisor

Scott

United States of America, February 2025

8.6/10

Our stay at Gurney's Star Island was simply delightful. The serene atmosphere, beautifully renovated spaces, and amazing service made for a great escape. However, I wished the beach access was a bit more impressive and the dining portions could be larger for the prices we paid. Overall, it's a wonderful retreat, particularly for those looking for a tranquil getaway.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms were spacious and beautifully updated with comfortable beds and high-quality linens.

Service

10.0

The service throughout our stay was outstanding; special thanks to Diana for keeping us hydrated and happy at the beach.

Location

7.0

While the hotel sits at a lovely marina, the beach area could use some improvement since it felt quite small compared to other locations.

Dining

8.0

Dining at Showfish was a highlight with fresh, creative dishes, though I found the portion sizes a bit on the smaller side.

Facilities

9.0

The facilities, including the pools and the private beach area with cabanas, were well-kept and enjoyable.

Harry

United States of America, February 2025

9.6/10

My stay at Gurney's Star Island was simply wonderful. The property is stunning, and the modern upgrades in the room made it truly feel like a vacation. The staff went above and beyond to make everything perfect. I especially loved the poolside service, which really enhanced the experience. While everything was impressive, I would love to see more options at the dining venues. Overall, it's a fantastic place to unwind and relax.

Rooms

10.0

The room was beautifully modernized, featuring a walk-in closet and a lovely balcony that added to the vacation feel.

Service

10.0

The staff was incredibly accommodating and attentive, making sure we had everything we needed.

Location

10.0

The hotel is ideally located with easy access to both the beach and the tranquil pool area.

Dining

9.0

The food quality at Showfish was impressive, offering fresh and creatively prepared dishes that delighted our taste buds.

Facilities

9.0

The facilities are fantastic, with a serene pool area and a variety of recreational activities available.

Modern room upgrades

Dining options could expand

Daniel

United States of America, December 2024

7.4/10

The resort has seen some nice renovations and offers a lovely ambience, but the inconsistent enforcement of safety protocols left me feeling uneasy. The rooms are spacious and clean, with beautiful beach access. However, the service fell short at times, particularly with the dining experience and staff responsiveness to safety concerns.

Rooms

9.0

The waterfront room we stayed in was spacious, clean, and had a private patio just steps from the beach, making it perfect for relaxing and enjoying the view.

Service

5.0

While some staff were attentive and prompt, I found the service to be a bit inconsistent overall, particularly during busy periods. There was a lack of action taken regarding safety breaches that affected my comfort.

Location

8.0

The resort is well-situated with close access to the beach and hotel amenities, although it felt crowded at times, especially on weekends.

Dining

7.0

The food at the restaurant was surprisingly delicious, but the service at the poolside was quite disorganized and left a lot to be desired.

Facilities

8.0

The pool and surrounding areas were well-maintained, creating a pleasant environment to relax in after a day on the beach.

Bernard

United States of America, November 2024

9.6/10

My stay at the Montauk Yacht Club was nothing short of magical. The serene setting with gorgeous views made it an ideal getaway. The spacious and comfortable rooms truly felt like my home away from home. While the dining experience at Ocean Club was exquisite, the presence of the managing director's adorable husky, Teddy, was a delightful bonus. However, my only complaint would be the occasional noise from other guests, which disrupted the tranquility. Overall, I can't wait to return to this charming resort!

Rooms

9.0

The rooms are spacious and comfortable, with firm beds and high-quality linens, making them perfect for a restful night.

Service

9.0

The service was attentive and friendly, from the warm welcome at check-in to the exceptional dining experience.

Location

10.0

Nestled right at the tip of Montauk Island, the location offers beautiful views and a tranquil atmosphere, perfect for relaxation.

Dining

10.0

Dining at the Ocean Club was amazing, with every dish being beautifully crafted and delicious, making it an unforgettable culinary experience.

Facilities

10.0

The facilities, including the spa housed on a yacht, are luxurious and enhance the overall relaxation of the stay.

Milton

United States of America, October 2024

9.6/10

Gurney's Star Island Resort provides a serene and upscale escape with beautiful marina views and a tranquil atmosphere. The amenities are extensive, including a lovely beach area and a fantastic restaurant, though the prices may be steep for some. The staff is consistently attentive and friendly, making your stay enjoyable. However, for those not fond of dogs, the pet-friendly policy might be a drawback.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms were spacious and clean, featuring a lovely balcony that overlooked the marina, which was a highlight of our stay.

Service

10.0

The staff were incredibly accommodating, especially at the beach and restaurants, ensuring we had everything we needed for a relaxing time.

Location

10.0

The resort is beautifully situated right on the marina, enhancing the vacation experience with easy access to the beach and recreational activities.

Dining

9.0

Dining at Showfish was a delight; the food was fresh and creatively prepared, making it a memorable experience.